Wednesday, 17 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 13: Evil. (i)

Joseph Stalin in 1934 
"Dictators have long realized the ideological importance of the past and have sought to wield archaeology as a political tool. There are numerous examples of this, and they have been well described and analyzed: German archaeology under Hitler, for instance, or the Soviet-style archaeology that formed under Stalin. In each case, the past was deliberately and systematically manipulated. Sometimes the material record itself was distorted or destroyed (as has also occurred in recent years in the Balkans and Middle East). but more often archaeological concepts and theoretical positions were appropriated, some being privileged over others. As it advances under totalitarian dictatorship, this process—the official, often legislated promotion of one version of the past to the exclusion of others—may be disastrous for archaeology, and for some archaeologists it becomes deadly. Stalin murdered or enslaved eighty-five percent of Russian archaeologists between 1930 and 1934."
Michael L. Galaty and Charles Watkinson, The Practice of Archaeology under Dictatorship, in: Archaeology Under Dictatorship (eds, Galaty and Watkinson), Springer, 2006, p. 2. [in-line refs. to all statements removed]

Detail from "Ectoplasm", Bill Donovan, New York, watercolour and ink on paper (in my collection: gift from the artist, 2009)

"If not controlled and manipulated, the past is always one of the biggest enemies of any totalitarian ideology. The plot was divided into three phases: 1) seduction, 2) temptation, and 3) "we've got you!" phase. The hook was to publish enthusiastic news about the successes of Polish archaeologists and subsequently to identify the most gifted among those who took the bait, as the competitive exam to enter the faculty of archaeology was extremely demanding. Quickly arrived the second phase of the plot: the temptation. Graduates were offered a perspective to achieve their dreams, to plan professional careers and to reach a relatively prestigious social status. Initially it seemed great but finally it turned out not be free of charge. The more one progressed in research, the more difficult was to secure funds. The first "glass ceiling" appeared. To get through it seemed simple - a member of the Communist Party (often a faculty member) would suggest: "Why won't you join the Communist Party? It is not a big deal really and, after all, you owed it to our Party, which already helped you so much." This is when the third "we've got you!" phase materialized. It was the crucial moment that the regime counted on a lot. Sometimes the plot was successful, but in majority of situations it didn't produce the wished effects."
Andrzej Boguszewski (Institut National de Recherches Archéologiques Préventives) The massive corruption of clever minds, TAG2010: 32nd annual meeting of the Theoretical Archaeology Group, Bristol, 17th-19th Dec 2010: Archaeology under communism: political dimensions of archaeology.
All of the above can stand on their own. No commentary is needed.


John's Coydog Community page

Tuesday, 16 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 12: Nationalism as religion.

U.N. Headquarters, Manhattan

"Nationalism, as the guiding frame of meaning of the nation, a process of imaginary construction of of society, can be also seen as religion, a secular religion that worships icons ..., engages in its own rituals and ceremonies, complete with its liturgical texts and hymns..." 
Yannis Hamilakis, The Nation and its Ruins: Antiquity, Archaeology and National Imagination in Greece, Oxford, 2007, p.16.


In this view of nationalism, the only division from any other religion is the word "secular", but we have entered a time in which the parameters of its definitions are starting to break down: we cannot define a religion as the belief in a god as two of the top five religions in the world (Chinese folk religion and Buddhism) do not focus on any god. In the primary definition of secular: denoting attitudes, activities, or other things that have no religious or spiritual basis, the word religious, denoting that which binds, can be equally given to all religions and nationalism alike. This leaves spiritual which means: of, relating to, or affecting the human spirit or soul as opposed to material or physical things. In the microcosm, quantum physics has proven that there are forces at play that can be called neither material or physical: the double-slit experiment violates classical logic merely by saying that an electron can be a wave or not a wave (a particle); both A and non-A. But also, with any interaction we have with the electron, it continues being whichever one we decided at the outset: being treated as a particle, it continues to be a particle and does not suddenly change to a wave, and vice versa. It has also been proven that paired particles each with opposite spins will appear to communicate their state with each other instantly even though being light years apart, so if one particle is made to spin right, its partner will then spin left at that very moment. This violates Einstein's relativity. In the macrocosm, both Stephen Hawking and Saint Augustine (354-430 AD) agree that time, itself, came into being with the creation of the universe. However, Stephen Hawking is an atheist. Although having its origins in both religious philosophy and alchemy, the Unus Mundus has recently become of great interest to both psychologists and quantum physicists where it is now referred to as the psychophysical universe and its basis is the participatory nature of the observer.

But coming down from such lofty heights, we only need observe the behaviour of nationalists so see that it is no different, whatsoever, from that of religionists. Hamilakis after talking more about its rituals and the transformation of material archaeological remains into symbols of belief  and ideology goes on to say:
"This dynamism gives it some of its enormous power and resilience, and at the same time warns us against any simplistic academic treatment. Rather than seeing it as exclusively a state affair, a top-down construction imposed upon the people by state bureaucrats and intellectuals, I am arguing for its simultaneous construction both from below and and from above. Nor should it be assumed that I am constructing here and image of an Orwellian nightmare which sees nationalist domination everywhere, with no opportunities for resistance. As will be shown elsewhere in this book, there are several instances where nationalistic ideologies in fact fuel, empower, and and incite resistance against the state or other power mechanisms, and in several cases social agents have been successful in negating and defeating the dominant authorities" (p. 17f ).
The key term here is "social agents", that is that the bottom-up movement consists of groups of people who share an opposing view and their numbers are instrumental in change. The base idea, in any single case, could have originated with an individual or it might have been through the coalescing of a group dynamic into an idea in an evolutionary fashion, but it has no power within the realm of the individual: it is a group action in reality.

Culture, on the other hand, is something that the individual expresses and as it consists of multiple cultural frames there will be no two individuals who have exactly the same culture and the groups are formed through overlapping areas of cultural expression. these, in turn, can produce changes in nationalism. Nationalism, however, can produce no change in culture as culture is an ever changing evolutionary pattern that is fulfilled only by individuals through various "quantum leaps" from psychic material in their own heads.

The empowerment supplies groupthink as a substitute for original idea and when this is adopted and expressed as "what I think" (or as an unthinking meme posing as such) it can generate the necessary brain chemicals to produce pleasure. This then acts somewhat like an evolutionary change except that it cannot, then, adapt to any new condition: it continues only in a mechanistic way and a person, if they did  experience a subsequent mental quantum leap, would in that same instant, remove themselves from the group and become a fully cognizant individual again.

"Cultural heritage" is thus a false term as it really only is an expression of nationalism and this is very apparent as it is only framed within the nation as an indivisible body. In each case, we have to decide whether it is an honest error in reason or merely a PR psychological trap to capture individuals and turn them into another member of the collective. Its real action actually halts culture and connects culture to static symbols which cannot change. It thus destroys culture in a very real sense. It becomes thus an enantiodromia.

The pattern of the combined top-down, bottom up nationalistic process is the seal of Solomon where the triangle with its base at the bottom is the social agency and the triangle with its base at the top is the causation of the state. The hexagon in the middle is the static state (shared cultural frames) where influences from both exist in an unchanging harmony which does not evolve. To change it back to a religious symbol is just to substitute state for heaven and social agency for earth. In nature, when bubbles are pressed together and all forces from all directions stop movement you get, in section, the stable hexagon. This is quite different from the structure of the yijing where the Yin and Yang lines are in a constant state of movement and interaction and represent (among many other things) the ever-changing nature of culture. Any change in the internal nature of the hexagram must come about, first, from an individual (whether it be from a genius altruistic individual or a powerful dictator) and a new stable state will then result which will continue until the next dramatic change. Culture, however, is always in a state of steady change.


John's Coydog Community page

Monday, 15 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 11: Nationalist appropriation and destruction of cultural history.

top: Parthenon in 1821 (Edward Dodwell); bottom: in 2004 (uncertain - cropped) 






























"... the changes that the site had undergone were phenomenal. The visual impression of the Acropolis in the pre-Independence era, partly preserved through drawings and engravings of the period must have been stunning and totally unfamiliar to present-day eyes: it was a palimpsest of human activity, and a monumental legacy of the attraction and multiple meanings of the site for diverse groups and people; ... there were traces of post-classical activity, with the most prominent the Ottoman mosque inside the the Parthenon (with its minaret which survived until 1843), the houses and other buildings for the garrison stationed on it, and the the remnants of the western occupation of Athens, with the most impressive being the highly visible medieval tower at the Propylaia.
"Most of these buildings were destroyed in the decades following the foundation of the state, with the medieval tower surviving until the mid-1870s. The demolitions and clearings which were started by the team set up by Klenze were continued by the Athens Archaeological Society, which together with the State Archaeological Service were the two bodies responsible for most of the archaeological activity at the time. The destruction of virtually all post-classical buildings was a ritual purification of the site from what were seen as remnants of 'barbarism' and the material manifestations of the occupation of Greece by foreign invaders."
Yannis Hamilakis, The Nation and its Ruins: Antiquity, Archaeology and National Imagination in Greece, Oxford, 2007, p. 88 (footnotes and refs. removed).
It was not just Ottoman remains that were destroyed in Athens: A decree in 1837 was made to stop the continuous destruction of Byzantine antiquities and in an 1843 decree, churches and other recent buildings were protected. Yet, in an earlier time the closest cultural connections the people were with the Christian remains and the earlier classical remains were seen as "works of the 'Hellenes', people who were seen as distinctive an different from the contemporary ones, living in another time, the mythical time of the Hellenes." (ibid. p. 67). Hamilakis points out that the latter categorization was promoted by the Church at the time. Fortunately, those remains were not swept away but tolerated. We can imagine a situation whereby culture D removes all traces of earlier cultures A, B, and C, and then are conquered by culture E who then removes all traces of culture D. In current times, modern societies condemn less modern societies for doing the same things the modern societies used to do in their earlier stages of development. This sort of thing is not restricted to the actions of religious fundamentalists like ISIS or the Taliban, but also to China with its developing industrialization and the resulting pollution. I can remember London when the buildings were black from soot, and in 1969 I saw in Los Angeles, a vapor trail from a jet plane where the pollution had changed it into a multi-coloured "oil-slick" in the sky. This is not "ancient history".

Athenian plated coin of the emergency issue of 406/5 BC
photo: Classical Numismatic Group, Inc.

Athens is the capital and largest city in Greece, but in the ancient Greek world, its economic and political dominance started in 480 BC with the Persian War and ended at the close of the Peloponnesian War (431-404 BC). Some people could have seen it start and finish.



But the Greek world was
Silver coin of Syracuse, Sicily, 405-400 BC
photo: Classical Numismatic Group, Inc.
much larger than the area Greece now occupies and after the decline of Athens, Syracuse, in Sicily became the "capital" of the Greek world. It boasted the largest population of any classical city: about half a million people (not that much smaller than Athens is now). Syracuse is the city where Archimedes leaped from his bath shouting "Eureka!" It attracted artists and intellectuals from all over the Greek world, and under Dionysios I (who issued the coin illustrated) resisted the power of the Carthaginians who had their eyes on the city. Of course, such coins as illustrated above are now claimed as the "cultural property" of Italy. Sicily became part of Italy in 1861.

The Fountain of Arethusa in Syracuse
photo: Giovanni Dall'Orto
The artist, Kimon of Syracuse chose his design well for the coin illustrated above: the head is that of the goddess Arethusa who, according to myth,fled from her home in Arcadia (Peloponnesus) under the sea to emerge as the fountain of Arethusa in Syracuse. You will also notice the proximity of later buildings and the spring  was arranged in its current semi-circular shape in 1847, utilizing part of the Spanish bulwark that had surrounded it since 1540. The cultural continuum is preserved.


John's Coydog Community page

Friday, 12 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 10: Collective "cultural heritage" and individual cultural evolution (v).

American WW2 poster
Yesterday, I linked to an article in Discover about how the human brain is shrinking, but one exception is with "Americans of European and African descent from colonial times up to the late 20th century". While genetic mixing make make up some of the phenomenon, there are many other places where this also happens but the U.S. was the only one where the brain size is increasing. The answer, then, lies more in an ability to adapt to new conditions. America, after the revolution expressed its independence with the phrase "Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness", but although that phrase is imprinted on the minds of all Americans we also have to consider what lies behind the words. In speaking of a 17th century alchemist, Jung said:
For Böhme a “high deep blue” mixed with green signifies “Liberty,” that is, the inner “Kingdom of Glory” of the reborn soul.
C. G. Jung, Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 9 (Part 1): Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious: 009 (Kindle Locations 5872-5873). Princeton University Press. Kindle Edition.
This is the psychic result in the minds of those partaking in any successful revolution, but again, there have been many successful revolutions which do not seem to have resulted in brains becoming larger. When we include the word "life", though, and take it past the fact of its physical existence we can start to zero in on the causes of this anomaly:
"Life proceeds, as it were, by making use of natural physical and chemical conditions as a means to its own existence. The living body is a machine for converting the energies it uses into other dynamic manifestations that are their equivalents. We cannot say that physical energy is transformed into life, only that its transformation is the expression of life."
C. G. Jung, Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 8: Structure & Dynamics of the Psyche: 008 (pp. 41-42). Princeton University Press. Kindle Edition.
Where the U.S. was different was that it had combined a revolutionary attitude with the fact of being in a relatively new and undeveloped country. The "pioneer spirit" exists, too, in Canada, but Canada experienced no revolution and remains part of the British Commonwealth. These two factors, in my opinion, combined to form "The American Dream" which embodied the idea of a meritocracy. Unfortunately, meritocracy has been poorly interpreted (for example in choosing intelligence as the main component and in applying Social Darwinism). It has also been poorly executed (so poorly that the title and theme of the linked article blames the very idea of meritocracy more than the failure to implement it).

All of these problems come about through groupthink but evolution has its core with the individual, and that brings us to the final component: happiness. When you succeed in something, you become happy. The brain rewards survival activities with feelings of pleasure. We have to be careful, though, that we do not develop an addictive personality where the happy feeling of success is too bound to the specific activity which caused it which then results in a constant repetition of that same activity (when that happens, the brain reduces the pleasure chemicals and the addict tries to compensate by doing even more of the same thing in the hope of regaining that one-time "high"). The brain is not just rewarding success, it is rewarding originality: the more good ideas you get, the better is the chance for your personal survival. Biological natural evolution rides on the back of individual evolution because those who survive better  live longer to produce more offspring and also attract mates. Any attempt to socialize this phenomenon inevitably runs into problems as is outlined in criticisms to Max Weber's The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. When things get really bad, there is a shift toward socialism which then starts to turn evolution toward a local need for a lack of originality. Remember, evolution is all about adaptation and survival in an environment. It is not a change to some envisioned ideal state of superiority in all things. The shark is a perfect model of successful evolution. Its tiny brain is concerned only with two things: eating and breeding and it has no need of innovation. Perhaps it has evolved to the point where it does not need to even feel pleasure. Is that where we want to go?

The human being evolved to be most successful as individuals within small extended family groups, and the larger human groups become; the larger and the more remote their governments become; the larger the submission to various collective "ism's", then the less intelligent, ambitious, innovative and happy we become in those environments.

I will be back on Monday with a new topic in this series. Have a happy weekend.


John's Coydog Community page

Thursday, 11 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 10: Collective "cultural heritage" and individual cultural evolution (iv).

My thinking about these topics has been greatly aided through reading about Symptom-Symbol Transformation (SST) in Remo F. Roth,  Return of the World Soul: Wolfgang Pauli, C.G. Jung and the Challenge of Psychophysical Reality, Vol. 1 and Vol. 2. While primarily used in therapy (linked page in German), Roth also explains how it might be used in more universal applications within the concept of the Unus Mundus.

In this section it is important to understand evolution as a system of adaptions to new realities. The idea of devolution gives credit to Neo-Darwinism which presupposes an ideal state to which evolution moves. We can actually quite easily evolve to a state of being where we would really not want to be. In fact, we seem (as a species) to be heading in that direction right now because of our (recent) move toward a smaller brain size. There are a number of theories that have been put forward for why this is happening but I feel that these are expressions of the blind men and an elephant parable. My American readers will happy to note that one study in the linked smaller brain size article revealed an example of the opposite:
"When anthropologist Richard Jantz of the University of Tennessee measured the craniums of Americans of European and African descent from colonial times up to the late 20th century, he found that brain volume was once again moving upward."
It did not say if American politicians' craniums were included in the study (sorry, I couldn't resist). I will offer my own interpretation of this anomaly tomorrow.

Collective "cultural heritage" is most often applied in a nationalistic manner (UNESCO, for example), but it is also marked by  great degree of fervor that is indistinguishable from religious fervor. Let us treat "cultural heritage" as a symptom and then look for the underlying symbol which will also reveal a very surprising example of the same thing: "cultural heritage" in its commonest application treats people as collectives bound by the state far more than even ethnic groups within a state (such people cannot, individually, obtain any rights through the various UNESCO conventions). What belongs to an ethnic group, belongs to the state. At the very bottom of the pile is the individual who is represented only within certain state-defined "stakeholders" representatives in any negotiations. Whether such people's opinions are actually taken into consideration or whether they are included to provide an apparency of such is a subject that has caused a considerable amount of discussion. I do know for a fact that the U.S. public's input and opinions about all of the recent U.S. State Department's Memoranda of Understanding (MoU's) with various countries concerning the import restrictions on ancient coins has been rejected in the final decisions to pass such MoU's despite overwhelming opposition from the public. The only public opinions which were followed came from those in academia, sometimes giving a "prepackaged" response. Nearly all of the responses, of course, were from individually motivated representatives of various cultural frames (i.e. stakeholders).

Another currently visible collective espousing "cultural heritage" is ISIS which takes the more obvious religious stance in the subject and bases its destruction of archaeological sites on its theories about iconoclasm  from the Islamic texts about worshiping graven images. Yet both groups are the same in that they reduce the free will of individuals in their interpretation of cultural matters to an overarching ideology. Both groups act with religious fervor but only ISIS cites that source. UNESCO-styled "cultural heritage" proponents offer up individuals as identical members of a state-controlled collective: "the public". They also appoint their group as overseers. Their (unconscious) religious fervor is exhibited by their moralistic terminology especially in the usage of the word "illicit". In Illicit heritage management in Austria? Raimund Karl says:
"For instance, a love affair may very well be illicit; that is, frowned upon by society because it is ‘immoral’; but perfectly legal; that is, not prohibited by any law. Calling something ‘illicit’ means ‘(some) people think it should not be done’, rather than ‘society has decreed by law that it must not be done’. And that is how we archaeologists like to use it when we talk about ‘illicit excavations’: excavations that ‘we archaeologists think should not be done’, rather than such that ‘the law says must not be done'.
Ray is very familiar with the religious and neurotic aspects of some of his peers as can be clearly seen in his paper on archaeologist's hoarding: Every sherd is sacred: compulsive hoarding in archaeology.

By taking the symptoms and transforming them into symbols we come closer to the root problem: both ISIS and the archaeological "cultural heritage" lobby are fighting a religious war and fanning each other's flames. It does us no good to ask who started it as each side will, like quarreling children, point to the other. But as a group of opposing energies united by the symbol matters will certainly escalate. Each benefits from this war, ideologically, and both gets lots of press through its sensationalism. They need each other to survive.

Scapegoating is another feature of this war: ISIS can point to people who are "falling from Grace" as it were and the archaeological  "cultural heritage" proponents can blame collectors for any looting (looting is always a phenomenon during wars). There is a recent, classic, example of the "scientific evidence-free" nature of reporting of the latter in Blood & Gold: Children Dying As Egypt's Treasures Are Looted . Its author, Owen Jarus being a Canadian freelance journalist who specializes in "Heritage" and archaeological reporting.

When you get such opposing forces both apparently surviving in a conflict it is a sign that the conflict is other that what it seems to be. I this case the conflict expresses a desire for power of the group over the individual and this is the base symbol. The conflict, on both sides, is really a political/economic power struggle.

The problem remains unsolvable (unless a third party come along to establish real power (like the parent or teacher who says "I don't care who started it...") because it only mimics any evolutionary process and can only result in its extinction for both sides. The reason being is that evolution is always energized through individual expression and without that as its source does not happen. I don't like to use the phrase "natural selection" as that opens up a can of worms noticed at first, statistically, by Wolfgang Pauli who envisioned some other force at play which later became part of epigenetics. I think "happenstance" is a better  word as it describes the phenomenon without assigning cause and some phenomena are acausal, anyway.

Heikegani crab (Heikeopsis japonica) photo: RD 77

My favorite example of this are some Japanese crabs that have a variable pattern of their surface shell structure: the Heikegani or "Samurai crab", which had been once assigned as an example of selective breeding, but more likely is an example of synchronicity where the archetypal Samurai face is an acausal creation of the Unus Mundus. But you would probably have to read Roth's book to understand how that can happen.


John's Coydog Community page

Wednesday, 10 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 10: Collective "cultural heritage" and individual cultural evolution (iii).

Did you know that Alberta is the only Canadian province where you can legally gather surface finds of stone tools and fossils? Some restrictions exist, such as in National Parks and First Nations Reserves and it does not give you the right to trespass on private property. Over the years, I had noticed a general decline in the public interest of collecting such things in Alberta and I had assumed that the laws prohibited it. The first thing I did this morning was to search Wikipedia Commons for some suitable images to make the graphic for this post. I did find an image of an Edmontosaurus (named after Edmonton, Alberta) that was not cluttered with too many extraneous details I would have to remove, but I could find no line drawings of Alberta (or even Canadian) projectile points. The Edmontosaurus, by the way, is not local but a specimen in the Yale Museum. The points I illustrate here are from New Jersey.

After that, I went searching to find out when the (imagined) laws had changed here to forbid the gathering of such things and discovered that it is still legal to do so. So why had the interest died down? The immediate thought was that people are far less interested in such things than they were fifty years ago, but that does not hold up very well to examination because there is still a great interest in the U.S. and Canadian and U.S. interests are not that different. Part of it might be that my fellow Albertans assume, just as I had, that there are prohibitory laws in existence and so have lost interest. That argument fails because any dealer in minerals and even antiques and curios would make themselves familiar with the laws of what they can and cannot deal in. I remember seeing quite a lot of artifacts and fossils at such trade shows here when I was young. Such shows (and flea markets) inspire many young people to start collecting examples of things that they happen to come across at some show.

We used to get American and British dealers setting up at local coin shows here but not anymore. The reason being that the Canadian government thought it would be a good idea to make all those dealers pay taxes on their stock and then apply for a refund later on what was not sold. There is a similar law, now in the U.S. so Canadian dealers also stay away from their shows, too. It's quite funny how bureaucrats always fail to see much beyond the end of their noses.  Of course, perhaps the actual point is to inhibit international trade for small businesses. Who knows? At  a Calgary coin show you can find dealers from other Canadian Provinces and Calgary coin dealers also set up tables at shows in other Provinces. Such trade represents quite a sizable amount of their business. People always prefer to buy something that they can examine in person.

So this situation seems to be the most likely reason that Alberta kids are not becoming as interested in collecting Canadian found fossils and arrowheads: there are few dealers from other Provinces at these shows bringing (or even owning) such things because of their laws. This difficulty does not exist with coins here, but it does in the U. S.: I know of a dealer in ancient coins from Minnesota who was forced to move away (he set up in Texas) because of a Minnesota State law that had nothing at all to do with ancient coins and was aimed at bullion traders only was so badly written that it had a disastrous effect on all collector coin dealers. the bureaucrats (who must have failed logic in school) thought that some bullion that is sold are coins therefore all coins that are sold are bullion. My friend Robert, who is a local coin dealer, missed out on exposing a very silly Calgary bylaw: All second-hand dealers here (and coin dealers are thus defined) must record all in-store purchases on an on-line police database. For coins, they have to write a description of each one. One day, a representative from Calgary Transit delivered to Robert's shop a large number of bags of foreign coins that had, over a long time, been deposited in the coin boxes on buses. There were so many bags and they were so heavy that Robert told the delivery men to stack them along the walls as he was concerned about that much weight sitting on the middle of his floor, somewhere. If he followed the bylaw, he would have spent many years just entering those coins into the police database. the coins, on average, had a retail value of about ten cents each. Assuming each coin took ten seconds to identify and enter into the database, Robert would be getting a potential $3.60 return on each hour's work. The city, of course, wanted Robert to pay them something for the coins. Really, they should have been paying him about $45 for every 360 coins he accepted as stock (if they expected the bylaw to be followed). The purpose of the bylaw was to recover stolen property and in all of the years it had been in effect, only one coin-related item was ever recovered by the police as stolen property. It was an Elvis medallion.

Apart from the sometimes serious, sometimes humorous, effect that such badly thought out laws have on people. They can also result in the extinction of certain cultural frames (such as, potentially, collectors and dealers). The public as a whole become lessened as a result of this because of the drastically reduced chance of new discoveries within the field which study the items that are collected. Not only would Sir John Evans never have come up with his major contributions to the development of modern archaeology which resulted from a quantum leap between his interests in numismatics (from an inherited coin collection) and geology, but academic systems are far too closed and intellectually regulated to allow for much original thought (see the quote from Aaron Lynch in the first part of this topic (i)). That is, other than the groupthink which marks the dull, bureaucratic mind.


John's Coydog Community page

Tuesday, 9 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 10: Collective "cultural heritage" and individual cultural evolution (ii).

"Pyrgi" gold tablets with bilingual inscription in
Etruscan and Phoenician
The extinction of a culture, in this part refers to both archaeological cultures and to cultural frames (see part seven). It does not refer to a modern nation which consists (mostly) of different cultures and (always) many cultural frames. One of the best known cultures that became extinct during the classical period is the Etruscans and with that went its language. We still have not been able to translate most of it. The "Pyrgi" tablets, far from being another Rosetta stone, allowed only one Etruscan word to be recovered: the word for "three". Everyone knows that it was the Romans who brought about the end of the Etruscan culture but the details given are not exactly accurate: It is said that Celtic invasions in northern Italy diminished Etruscan power and made it an easier target for Rome to finish off completely. Although the Celts had, much earlier, taken land from the Etruscans in order to build military bases in northern Italy, Etruria was still very wealthy and warfare was not just one culture fighting another but was carried out through the additional hire of various auxiliary regiments of outside cultures. This was why the Celts needed bases in the first place (about 400 BC). The real end is obliquely described by Livy (Book 10, 10.10). Livy is the ancient historian most quoted about the Celts in northern Italy. He is also a historical fabricator who might even rival Geoffrey of Monmouth in Wales. Livy's account of the Roman hero Camillus saving Rome from the Celts is pure fiction (Daniele Vitali, The Celts in Italy, in: Venceslas Kruta et al, (eds.), The Celts, 1999, New York, p. 232.) and with it might well go Juno Moneta's geese warning the Romans and the oft quoted "Woe to the vanquished". Nevertheless, embedded in Livy's imaginative and popular accounts is a shred of the truth. You just have to know how to read between the lines and look at other evidence. He says:
“The Etruscans also chose this year [299 B.C.] to prepare for war in contravention of the truce, but were diverted from their purpose for a little while by a huge army of Gauls which crossed their borders when they were busy with other things. They then tried to convert the Gauls from enemies to allies, relying on the money which gave them power, in order to fight the Romans with the two combined armies. The barbarian Gauls did not refuse an alliance; it was only a question of the price. This was agreed on and the money changed hands, but when the Etruscans had finished all the rest of their preparations for war and ordered the Gauls to follow them, the Gauls denied that the agreed payment was for making war on the Romans; anything they had received had been in return for not destroying Etruscan land and interrupting its cultivation by armed raids. However, they were willing to take up arms if the Etruscans really wanted them, but only on condition that they were admitted to a share in Etruscan land where they could at last settle in some definite home. Many councils of the people of Etruria were held to consider this request without reaching any decision, not so much out of reluctance to allow any reduction of territory but because everyone dreaded having men of so savage a race as his neighbour. The Gauls were accordingly dismissed, and went off with an enormous amount of money which they had acquired without effort or risk. At Rome the rumour of a Gallic rising in addition to an Etruscan war caused much alarm, and speeded up the conclusion of a treaty with the people of Picenum”
"but only on condition that they were admitted to a share in Etruscan land where they could at last settle in some definite home. ..." is more fiction. The Celts in question already had homes on the other side of the Alps and individual Celts had moved to northern Italy much earlier, some even marrying Etruscans. They did demand money, however, and perhaps by way of a "protection racket". It seems unlikely, though, that the Etruscans thought that they were buying troops with that money: the Celts, at that time would have thought that more generals would have need of their paid service and such a story of treachery going around would have been bad for future business. Celtic troops did not come cheap (probably due to Dionysius I of Syracuse's original generosity in hiring them): Rome's earlier ransom was paid by Massalian businessmen probably because they wanted Roman allies against the Etruscan and/or Carthaginian trade. Livy had invented the story about Camillus: Polybius had stated only that the ransom was paid, but gave no details. It was Pompeius Trogus who revealed the Massalian connection.

I believe that the Celts fees equated to about half of the Etruscan treasury or a little less. I base this on the existence of some Etruscan gold coins of about the same weight as each other but bearing both "5" and "10" as a unit of account. In other words, it created a 50% devaluation of Etruscan money. When this sort of thing happened before (as with the debasement of the coinage of Lesbos), only local troops would fight as foreign troops were paid by units of account. Much later, the British Durotriges tribe were in a similar position when Rome finally cut off Coriosolite billon (base silver) exports during the early part of Tiberius rule: after that, the Durotriges coinage became completely bronze but had the same unit of account. So the Etruscan economy became so weakened  that they were severely restricted in their hiring of auxiliaries and their fate was thus sealed.

Causality is a minefield as, while I could say that the Celts were thus responsible for the end of the Etruscans, the price-setting of Dionysius I and his very rise to power was instrumental. We could go even further back than that and what is really happening in these situations is the evolution of multiple cultural frames, each influencing the others. In physics terms it is strongly related to what David Bohm called the Implicate Order and which lead him (into another cultural frame) to suggest a new sort of grammar, the Rheomode. David Bohm (and, later, String Theorists) broke with the established quantum physics ideas of quantum leaps in seeking direct causal links. Both are, however, by their very natures, untestable. Even within quantum physics, Paul Dirac, who was an aetheist, had problems with some of its ideas and tried to reconcile it with Einsteinian relativity. One of Pauli's most famous quotes (after hearing Dirac talk about his atheism) was: "Well, our friend Dirac has got a religion and its guiding principle is 'There is no God and Paul Dirac is His prophet.'"

This brings us back again to Jung and Pauli's Unus Mundus and Synchronicity  and I have already paved the way for this understanding in previous parts of this series. In recent years, a number of people have been examining the Unus Mundus and dominating the research are Harald Atmanspacher and Remo F. Roth. Another development from quantum physics and which is especially related to to what I have been speaking of with regard to cultural evolution is transdisciplinarity with its leading proponent Basarab Nicolescu .

There are multiple cultural frames connecting every discipline and both quantum leaps and transdisciplinarity can reveal them. Preventing this holistic approach, certain aspects of any discipline can hit "dead ends", often posing as simplistic "solutions". In other words, the extinction of evolutionary cultural frames. In a conversation I had with Raimund Karl last year, he summed up the problem very well:
"...that, in many ways, is what makes our subject so exciting. The better you get to know the details, the more questions open up. The more you seem to understand something, the more you realise that you really don't understand tiddly squat about it. And that's how it should be: there is nothing more boring than an answer that doesn't create a bunch of new questions, an answer that stops us from feeling we need to progress even further but instead lets us think we have come to an end. Because ends almost invariably are dead ends." (one typo confirmed and corrected)

More tomorrow.



John's Coydog Community page

Monday, 8 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 10: Collective "cultural heritage" and individual cultural evolution (i).

Picasso, Les Demoiselles d'Avignon, 1907
"Cultural Heritage" is the excusing term used for the existence of "cultural property" and is a weak form of communist belief. The ideas of communism have been defined thus:
"All people are the same and therefore classes make no sense. The government should own all means of production and land and also everything else. People should work for the government and the collective output should be redistributed equally" (my italics).
This differs from socialism (in the same article):
"All individuals should have access to basic articles of consumption and public goods to allow for self-actualization. Large-scale industries are collective efforts and thus the returns from these industries must benefit society as a whole"(also my italics).
Self actualization is a term created by the German neurologist/psychiatrist Kurt Goldstein, but best expressed by the American psychologist Abraham Maslow who (inevitably) came up with the idea of peak experiences. One of the sources of such peak experiences are the psychological "quantum leaps" that are only particular to individuals and cannot occur within any collective psychological state. This fact is a major inhibitant to collectives such as academic institutions. Aaron Lynch attempts to find a solution:
"Practical implications may follow from the above model of population creativity for ideas. For example, proposals to make education highly uniform and enforced by nationwide testing may tend to limit creativity by reducing the variability of combinations of important ideas. Creativity in an organization or a society might alternatively be enhanced by encouraging the acquisition of highly unusual combinations of ideas and fields of learning. Cultural, educational, and experiential diversity might turn out to increase population creativity by increasing the occurrence rates for extremely rare combinations of ideas that could lead to the formation of new ideas. In particular, this might result in higher creative output for universities, research institutions, and other organizations that deliberately strive for a culturally diverse mix of people. Yet even a 1000-fold increase for an idea combination that exists at a prevalence of 10-9 only involves one person in a million, representing only a tiny dent in the prevalence for extremely common combinations of ideas that would form the mainstream of a society or a subculture."
Units, Events, and Dynamics in the Evolutionary Epidemiology of Ideas 
Picasso is said to have obtained his idea for the two heads on the right of  "Les Demoiselles d'Avignon" from African masks, but I also argue that there is much in that painting that was influenced by his visit to the Altamira Caves where he is reported to have said "After Altamira, all is decadence". To call Picasso "one in a million" we would have to severely restrict the pool by which the million is defined. in addition to the apparent impossibility of any dramatic difference in the incidents of creativity within an academic institution through Lynch's solution, the collective nature of any institution fights very hard to restrict individuality even more through peer-pressure and review. Individual academics who are already of high status can sometimes maintain enough of that individuality to make important new discoveries (providing these do not go against the mainstream parameters of the institution) but the institution, itself, is really a place where education should take place and not new research. It's value lies in providing a point of departure for discovery by providing the basics in any discipline so people can then leave and work on their own, communicating with other individuals in a setting that is absent from any hierarchy, collectivism or dogma. This is why the first half of the nineteenth  century produced such visionaries as Charles Darwin (and in archaeology, Sir John Evans): it was their practice to discuss their ideas at informal gatherings of people with similar passions. This was the last phase of the seventeenth to eighteen century cultural salons. Although it never entirely died out, the changes in universities toward the end of the nineteenth century lessened its influence. More appropriate to our times are the modern technical institutes and universities which communicate better with the private sector and the public at large.

Collectives inhibit personal adaptation and discovery is the fuel for deliberate species adaptation, but discovery has to be an individual event unless it is merely a linear progression from what had come before. In the latter scenario, no "quantum leaps" occur.

Proponents of "cultural heritage" and its dogma point only to individuals who have not made major contributions to any field in their criticisms because of their repression of the understanding of the need of very large population pools for discoveries to emerge, often through synchronicity as well as basic interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary practices. This repression seems to contain a good measure of narcissism where the individual associates his or herself only with the collective and feeds off its successes to compensate for their lack of personal discovery and ability. The collective itself, finding support from this, then validates and enables the narcissist element.

This lead us into the subject of extinction, and I will continue with this aspect in tomorrow's part. 



John's Coydog Community page

Friday, 5 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 9: the actual processes of culture (iii)

Siksika Nation (Blackfoot) elder texting with family looking on.
Of all of the photographs I took at this year's Calgary Stampede this is my favourite. It shows that while traditions can be maintained, a living culture must adapt to its environment to ensure its survival and prosperity.  In the eighteenth century, the Siksika Nation had a population of about 18,000 but disease brought by Europeans and the slaughter of bison herds including that by the Canadian government in order to starve out Sitting Bull's Sioux and force them to return to the U.S. greatly reduced that number. Now the population is 7,320, but only 4,025 still live on the reserve near Gleichen, Alberta. Part of their current prosperity has been brought about by their fight against illegal seizures of their land such as the land that had been given to the Canadian Pacific Railway for the construction of Bassano Dam. The Blackfoot-speaking cultures were also threatened with extinction through the Christian residential schools, and they were not the only First Nations victims of this oppression. Always warriors, their weapons now are legal cases and public relations projects.

Outside of the Blackfoot confederacy, efforts to "preserve the culture" suffer from a lack of understanding of the culture: as with many First Nations, the preservation of many artifacts and even human remains in museums goes directly against the culture. The key phrase in the following video is: "They say that when these symbols disappear from erosion then the story's finished":



Human remains, too, are supposed to return to nature and only when that happens will the spirit of that person be able to move on. This is also very similar, in part, to the Tibetan practice of sky burial where it is sometimes claimed by Tibetans to also ensure that the spirit does not stay too long with the body. Some First Nation's cultural objects, such as medicine bundles can be specifically bequeathed or are taken care of by appointed guardians; other objects are made by First Nations artists to be sold to whomever would desire them and the proceeds are used by the artists and their heirs to support their families. The objects, themselves, carry information about the culture far and wide; generate interest and in some cases can help to provide information back to the original culture when it becomes lost over time. Many years ago, I met a white woman who had restored much information to the Haida in British Columbia about their culture through such objects.

But all of the above is about living cultures. What of cultures long dead? Remember what I said in the previous part of this topic that cultures are not static and are carried forward by individuals in a very personal way. What do we really (mostly) experience at a museum? The buildings are often impressive monuments to the state: their spacious galleries and high ceilings dwarf the humans inside. This was the very point of such architecture from the Byzantine through western European cathedrals to the buildings of Hitler's architect Albert Speer. Subservience to the state or Church was the purpose. Within the museum, objects can be behind glass or ropes and there will be attendants to make sure that you do not touch what is not. I have not seen it since the building has been renovated, but I hope it is still there, but in Devonian Gardens in Calgary there stood a life size bronze sculpture of Labrador retriever by Sir Edwin Landseer. The artificial patina on its nose worn down by generations of children who had petted it. Do you believe that the artist would have been upset by such activity, or do you think that he would have been pleased that his work had become so believable? Sculptors say that their work is made to be handled. I once encouraged my daughter to run her hands over a marble sculpture by Jean (Hans) Arp. A museum attendant rushed over to stop us doing that.

Decades ago, a study was undertaken to track the movements of visitors to a large museum. It was discovered that at first the visitors would walk slowly around looking at he exhibits. after a while they would walk faster with and with a growing apparency of panic would soon start looking for the nearest exit. They were suffering from sensory overload. Such an experience probably kept them out of museums for some time afterward. Once,  a tourist at the British Museum asked me for directions to the Rosetta Stone. I took her over to it and she glanced at it quickly and then walked off. Clearly, it was on her "must see" check list. She could tell people she had seen it. I have been to art exhibit openings where the elite have been sipping wine and talking to each other. They were there to be seen, not to look. When exhibits fail to interest or they are not part of the collecting focus of the museum, they are stored away and rarely seen again. Whenever one is deaccessioned and sold, however, the public (who never went to see it anyway) is encouraged to protest the sale by cultural heritage neurotics. A friend was on an archaeological did in Tuscany and after the dig, all Etruscan undecorated black bucchero ware pots had to be smashed with hammers. The local storage was full of the stuff and they did not want such things "getting into the hands of collectors" because it would encourage looting.

The word "museum" comes from Muse, and the purpose of the Muse is to inspire the production of art. Through such inspiration, even extinct cultures do not completely die away and get forgotten. They pass something of themselves onto future generations. Only when people lose personal contact with a culture does it really die. Academics often assume that the purpose of a museum is to educate. They are merely projecting their own psychology onto the public. Picasso would see and would purchase African carvings from street vendors in Paris (who were from French Africa). The art inspired him and part of that culture lived on his work and changed the course of European art. It is always the individual who does this. So what is wrong with these neurotics who restrict culture (besides propping up nationalisms) and who become fanatical without ever evolving their ideas about the subject? Jung explains:
"If the subjective consciousness prefers the ideas and opinions of collective consciousness and identifies with them, then the contents of the collective unconscious are repressed. The repression has typical consequences: the energy-charge of the repressed contents adds itself, in some measure, to that of the repressing factor, whose effectiveness is increased accordingly. The higher its charge mounts, the more the repressive attitude acquires a fanatical character and the nearer it comes to conversion into its opposite, i.e., an enantiodromia. And the more highly charged the collective consciousness, the more the ego forfeits its practical importance. It is, as it were, absorbed by the opinions and tendencies of collective consciousness, and the result of that is the mass man, the ever-ready victim of some wretched “ism.” The ego keeps its integrity only if it does not identify with one of the opposites, and if it understands how to hold the balance between them. ...
"The current “isms” are the most serious threat in this respect, because they are nothing but dangerous identifications of the subjective with the collective consciousness. Such an identity infallibly produces a mass psyche with its irresistible urge to catastrophe. Subjective consciousness must, in order to escape this doom, avoid identification with collective consciousness by recognizing its shadow as well as the existence and the importance of the archetypes. These latter are an effective defence against the brute force of collective consciousness and the mass psyche that goes with it.
Jung, C. G.. Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 8: Structure & Dynamics of the Psyche: On the Nature of the Psyche (pp. 218-221). Princeton University Press. Kindle Edition. 
"The neurotic is forced by his neurosis to take this step, but the normal person is not. Instead, he acts out his psychic disturbances socially and politically, in the form of mass psychoses like wars and revolutions. The real existence of an enemy upon whom one can foist off everything evil is an enormous relief to one’s conscience. You can then at least say, without hesitation, who the devil is; you are quite certain that the cause of your misfortune is outside, and not in your own attitude. Once you have accepted the somewhat disagreeable consequences of interpretation on the subjective level, however, the misgiving forces itself on you that it is surely impossible that all the bad qualities which irritate you in others should belong to you. By that token the great moralist, the fanatical educationist and world-improver, would be the worst of all."
ibid. (p. 272). 

I will be back with more in this series and a new topic on Monday, Have a cultural evolutionary weekend.


John's Coydog Community page

Thursday, 4 August 2016

The "cultural heritage" group neurosis 9: the actual processes of culture (ii)

The term "quantum leap" applied to a sudden shift in thought about something can come about wholly within the psyche through the linking of formerly disparate mental pictures or ideas or through dream imagery where a solution from the unconscious, usually of an archetypal nature, is given when the consciousness cannot resolve a problem. Probably the most famous example of a mental quantum leap is where Archimedes realized the displacement of the water level in his bath and came up with the solution to discovering whether his patron, Hiero II's new gold crown had the correct amount of gold in its alloy. This discovery, was not entirely happenstance, though. Archimedes was in an "altered state" merely because he was relaxing in a bath. Other mental quantum leaps have taken place through hallucinogenic drugs or the shaman's drum, and even through the practice of poetry (especially obsessive verse). All of these things and more can stimulate the unconscious. The most skeptical of medical doctors can talk about the "placebo effect" and be completely oblivious to the fact that they have just endorsed telekinesis on a cellular level.

If the resulting cognition is important enough, it can result in a direct change in a culture. Less important, and more frequent mental quantum leaps can have a cumulative effect and appear to show a culture evolving. All of these, however, virtually only happen to a single person. On a rare occasion, two people if they are "in sync" can come up with an idea or a solution at the same time, but the skeptic could offer various "logical" reasons as to why this occurred. If eight people in a room did this, though, parapsychology would suddenly move from theories to fact.

So let's imagine these eight people in a room at time when one of them has a mental quantum leap. The scenario being that they are not random people in a waiting room, but people who are working together on some project. As they all share a very similar mental set (or cultural frame), the realization of one of them is more likely to be understood and find agreement by the others. It would also be most likely that not only a project is being shared, but a specific stage of that project was being discussed at that time. Furthermore, the seven people who witness this quantum leap are familiar enough with the other person's base mental and emotional state to be able to recognize an altered state. Having all had such experiences, themselves, even if with something as mundane as being roused by a piece of music, or seeing a painting. They thus gain a sense of importance about what has been discovered and give it the requisite attention. It does not even matter if the idea is valid: if it is invalid, those working on problem has just been made aware of a false assumption that had not been previously identified and steps can then be taken to ensure that this would not be repeated in the future. Most often, though, the quantum leap is valid within the given parameters of the group. This local culture has just taken an evolutionary step.

But what would happen if these same eight people were dotted about in an organization of two thousand people; were working on different projects on different floors of a large office building? They would know each other less, if at all. The person who makes a quantum leap might email the idea to his manager and the idea might be evaluated  by completely false criteria such as the status of the employee; their work history; the mood of the manager at the time and his or her's personal psychology; professional jealousies, the list goes on. Most often the idea would die because it was not mutually experienced to some degree. Of the eight people, it would be most likely that only the originator of the idea would know about it. the manager would be less likely to be one of the eight because the mental environment in the first scenario would be lessened by the absence of a shared status. The dynamics of boss and employees injecting too many other factors and the quantum leap might never have taken place at all.

Now let us take this quantum leap to the next step and assume that it has been adopted by the local culture (the small group) and has also found favour with larger groups within the society (the company, organization, or right up to nation). What starts as a psychic phenomenon then shifts to a material one and can only progress through mechanistic methods which will inhibit or even eliminate the likelihood of further quantum leaps. The larger culture slows its development. If the idea becomes policy or dogma, it cannot evolve at all, and if the culture has too much of this sort of thing it will cease to evolve or adapt and will certainly fail at some point. As Bob Dylan once wrote: "Those who are not busy being born are busy dying". A static point cannot maintain.

If the quantum leap had, instead of moving to a much larger group, been shared with other small groups, then the dynamic allows proliferation: the idea than can become paired with with another idea for the first time and another quantum leap can then take place. The evolution of the small, interacting groups speeds up.

Ponder all of this, and I will continue with more on it tomorrow.


John's Coydog Community page